Outer Rim Territories

Musings, ramblings, and nonsense from the fringe of space and time

« Back to blog

You Want to Be a Pastor? Be Something Else First

Touchstone Magazine - Mere Comments: You Want to Be a Pastor? Be Something Else First

We are not speaking here of the incursion of the know-it-all clerical whippersnapper who steams into a church to reform it according to his own bright lights or formulas for success he has learned in some ridiculous Practical Theology faculty, but rather the pastor who finds, as one so often does, heresy or immorality that must be dealt with, and purposes to deal with it. There are great advantages in such a case to be operating, and to be known to be operating, from a position of financial independence. Challenging the malignancy has a cost, and it is wise to be able to cover it before one begins the work.
The day and age when a pastor can challenge a congregation to be orthodox without serious consequence are gone. In the corporate world, we called this job security. It would appear the author would only advocate second-career pastors.... Is his fear reasonable that pastors will be reserved in their preaching of Law in fear of losing their financial ability to support their family? It almost makes you wish to return to a system of Bishops, taking the congregation out of the mix. It makes sense that some might adjust their giving based on the preaching of the pastor. Sad... but true. What do you think?

Jul 14, 2006
Tom B. said...
I know that I feel pretty blessed to have had the 19 year career first, and that I am so much better off having had the 16 extra years working after my first inclination to enter the seminary. I like having that extra perspective.

However, I don't consider my career one that I could just go back to if things didn't "work out" in the church. How many careers are like that anymore? How would you stay remotely up-to-date in any technologically related business to prepare for a possibility of having to return (while REALLY giving all you had to the work of the church)? Seems like a "doomed to failure as a pastor" thing if you took that direction.

Maybe if you were a landscaper, or baker, or chef, or something else that has kind of "timeless" skills - that would be the kind of "something else" to be first.

In our current environment, yeah, I'm concerned about the consequences of preaching the Word and administering the sacraments rightly. But I'm not promised "worldly success".

Jul 14, 2006
Christopher Gillespie said...
Indeed. It seems the author's suggestion is inherently selfish. Yes, I am concerned about my family's well being. Yes, I want them to be fed and clothed. Whether I am a pastor or a lay person, I trust that God will "provide all that i need to support this body and life."

I suppose in an Evangelical culture this might be different. There they have no catholic understanding of providence. Everything is conditional on you... So if you can't feed the family it is your fault. Yuck. So the pastor holds his tongue when it should be the sword of truth and he yields to his selfish needs.

I applaud those young people who have the Kahunas to go to semianry straight from undergrad. That's faith!